A genetic test of a migration from India to Europe
E' stato pubblicato online l'importante articolo del genetista americano P.A. Underhill (et alia) sul gruppo genetico R1a ( http://www.scribd.com/doc/23322591/Underhill-Et-Al-2009-Separating-the-Post-Glacial-Coancestry-of-European-and-Asian-Y-Chromosomes-Within-Hap-Lo-Group-R1a ).
La mappa in verde qui sopra mostra la frequenza dell'aplogruppo R1a1a-M17, quella in rosso l'età calcolata in diverse regioni dell'Eurasia. Appare chiaramente che l'area più antica comprende il Sind e il Gujarat, con un'espansione verso ovest che trova nuove apparenti aree di irradiazione nel Caucaso e in Polonia. Si dice nell'articolo: "Analysis of Associated STR diversity profiles Revealed That Among the R1a1a * (xM458) chromosomes is the Highest Observed Diversity Among Populations of the Indus Valley Coalescent times yielding above 14 KYA (Thousands of years ago), Whereas the diversity declines R1a1a * WHERE Toward Europe ITS Coalescent times of maximum diversity and 11.2 KYA are Observed in Poland, Slovakia and Crete. "
Then, in the Indus Valley is the oldest haplogroup R1a1a 12000 BC, while in Poland, Slovakia and Crete dates back to 9200 BC.
again: "Also noteworthy is the drop in diversity R1a1a * away from the Indus Valley Toward Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan 5.6 KYA) and the Altai region (8.1 KYA) that marks the eastern boundary of significant R1a1a* spread”.
Quindi, nel Kirghizistan, che pure ha un'alta percentuale di individui portatori di R1a1a, l'antichità di questo aplogruppo appare risalire solo al 3600 a.C., nell'Altai al 6100 a.C.
Quindi, sulla base di questi calcoli arriviamo alla conclusione che una popolazione sudasiatica si diffuse prima verso l'Europa, e più tardi verso l'Asia centrale. Non c'è dunque una migrazione antica dall'Europa verso l'Asia meridionale, o dall'Asia centrale verso quella meridionale, ma l'opposto.
Se vogliamo collegare l'aplogruppo R1a1a con gli Indoeuropei, idea che rimane attractive, since it seems to be the only haplogroup frequencies that combining with significant Indo-Aryan, Iranian, Anatolian, Greek, Slavic and Germanic (not Celtic or Romance language speakers), we should admit that the origin of the Indo-Europeans and South Asia, and not in Eastern Europe. Here, we find a mutation dell'aplogruppo, called by Underhill R1a1a7:
"In Europe a large Proportion of the variation is represented by ITS R1a1a presently R1a1a7-M458 subclade Identified That is Virtually absent in Asia. Its major Relatively low frequency and diversity in Europe Can Be Explained by a founder effect Thus That According To Our Coalescent time estimation falls into the early Holocene period, 7.9 ± 2.6 KYA. The Highest regional date of 10.7±4.1 KYA among Polish R1a1a7 carriers falls into the period of recolonization of this region by Mesolithic (Swiderian and subsequent cultures) settlers. […] It should be noted, though, that the inevitably large error margins of our coalescent time estimates do not allow us to exclude its association with the establishment of the mainstream Neolithic cultures, including the Linearbandkeramik (LBK), that flourished ca. 7.5-6.5 KYA BP in the Middle Danube (Hungary) and was spread further along the Rhine, Elbe, Oder, Vistula river valleys and beyond the Carpathian Basin.”
Quindi, sembra che l'R1a1a7 sia sorto in Polonia tra il 12800 e il 4600 a.C., in una cultura that may be the Mesolithic or Neolithic Linear Pottery which spread between Hungary, the Balkans, Germany and Poland ( http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultura_della_ceramica_lineare ). In this ; so, the people in Eastern dell'R1a1a bearer may be associated with the Neolithic revolution in this area.
The antiquity of this subclade and its absence in Asia show that there has been migration from Europe to Central Asia in recent times: "although the frequency and diversity is R1a1a * Highest Among Indo-Aryan and Dravidian speakers , the subhaplogroup R1a1a7 M458-frequency peaks Among Slavic and Finno-Ugric peoples. Although this distinction is not by geography Directly information about the internal divisions of These Families separate language, It Might bear burdens for Assessing Significance dispersal That Have Been Proposed models to explain the spread of Indo-Aryan languages \u200b\u200bin South Asia as It Would exclude Any Significant patrilineal gene flow from Europe to East Asia, at least since the mid-Holocene period. "
Since the Middle Holocene is the period around 4000 BC, this means that after that time, which is the minimum limit for the source subclade of R1a1a7, we can not assume a migration from Europe to Asia Central and South America, and this refutes all theories that assume that the people of the Kurgan region of the Black Sea went to Afghanistan during the civilization of Bactria and Margiana (BMAC, the III-II mill BC.) , and then in India (II mill. BC).
On the other hand, migration of people from South Asia to Europe dell'R1a1a appears much older than it is normally assumed for the diffusion of Indo-European languages, before the Bronze Age, during the period Mesolithic or Neolithic. So if we connect with the R1a1a Indo-European speakers, we must pre-date questa diffusione, e vedere gran parte dell'Europa neolitica come già indoeuropea, rovesciando la teoria di Gimbutas sull'Europa antica, pre-Kurgan, come un mondo agricolo pacifico non indoeuropeo. D'altronde, anche un sostenitore dell'ipotesi Kurgan come Villar ha riconosciuto nella toponimia iberica uno strato indoeuropeo risalente all'epoca neolitica. Quanto all' Alteuropäisch del Krahe, ovvero quella terminologia che si trova solo nelle lingue indoeuropee d'Europa centrale e occidentale, ma non in greco o in sanscrito, potrebbe essere legata al popolo dell'R1a1a7, che, significativamente, è assente anche in Grecia. Tale data antica dell'arrivo dei portatori dell'R1a1a and Indo-European languages, however, contradicts the theory of continuity of the paleolithic Alinei and Costa, because it gives people a pre-Indo-Paleolithic cultures.
Moreover, not all R1a1a R1a1a7 in Europe, so maybe we can not exclude subsequent migrations of peoples from Asia to Europe, bringing the Indo-European languages \u200b\u200b(including greek, much closer to Sanskrit or all 'Iran of other European languages), we have examples of migration to Europe of the Iranian people as the Scythians, Sarmatians and Alans, and Roma and Sinti in India, even in historical times.
0 comments:
Post a Comment