Monday, December 27, 2010

Funbrain.com Planetary Pinball

Ardor and history - two thousand judgments



Now that I'm finally in the hands of Calasso remarkable book, I can make a correction: it is not that our author is unaware of the alternative theories, rather than the liquid in summary, probably following Witzel, mentioned several times, though not in this regard. Calasso writes (p.26):
"In recent years there has been a headlong quest to dig up the bones of a horse from Punjab. Wielded as weapon, should serve to disperse and vanquish the hated Indo-European came from outside , beyond the Khyber Pass, showing that they are new - the horse - already belonged to those places. [...] As for the warriors in chariots with horses, there is no trace in the seals of the Indus civilization. "

For warriors mounted on horses (no carts), wait for the findings of Piraka in Baluchistan, after 1800 a.C. (vedi qui per un'immagine). Come nota giustamente Calasso, l'uso vedico del cavallo, come in Medio Oriente e in Egitto nel II millennio a.C., è associato al carro, di cui il Nostro dice altrove parlando degli Ārya (pp.19-20): "Si muovevano periodicamente su carri con ruote provviste di raggi. Quelle ruote furono la grande novità che apportarono: prima di loro, nei regni di Harappa e Mohenjo-daro si conoscevano solo le ruote compatte, solide, lente."

Questo è un tipico mito della scuola invasionista: come si può vedere dalle due immagini sopra, a sinistra troviamo su una tavoletta convessa di Harappa il simbolo della ruota con raggi (vedi l'immagine con commento alla pagina  http://www.harappa.com/indus/90.html ), che qui appare isolato, ma è usato comunemente nella 'scrittura vallinda'. A destra vediamo invece ruote giocattolo dai siti di età harappana Banawali e Rakhigarhi (nello stato indiano dello Haryana) con evidente indicazione di raggi, dipinti e in rilievo.

Secondo mito: l'assenza del cavallo nei siti 'harappani'. Qui a sinistra (dall' articolo di Michel Danino The Horse and the Aryan Debate ) abbiamo una statuetta di terracotta da Mohenjo daro: anche se non particolarmente dettagliata (cosa normale per questo genere of artefacts), the length of the neck, slender figure, the tail, are identified with the horse, as did Mackay in 1943. Another terracotta figurine of a horse with the body and tail is typically one to the right, from the mature Harappan site of Lothal in Gujarat. Other examples can be found in the same article (a small horse's head between the game pieces!) And in ' article Rajaram of Vedic-Harappan Gallery . Although these are a few illustrations, this seems to be the norm in India before the third century. BC, Danino noted in the aforementioned article: "" the first deliberate and conscious attempt of shaping a horse in a durable material like stone Was Witnessed in the art of the Mauryas in India, "writes historian TK Biswas. Another historian, Jayanti Rath, commenting on the animals depicted on early Indian coins, remarks: "The animal world of the punch-marked coins Consists of elephant, bull, lion, dog, cat, deer, camel, rhinoceros, rabbit, frog, fish, turtle, ghariyal (fish eater crocodile), scorpion and snake. Among the birds, peacock is very popular. The lion and horse symbols Appear To Have Greater Acquired popularity in 3rd century BC ""
We might also add that in the hymns of the Rigveda the animal most recurrent and stands as a symbol is the horse, but the bull (along with cow): Agni , Indra and other gods are often called 'bulls' ( VRSA), and this agrees with the predominant iconography of bovine Harappan seals. Also, when the poet-priests celebrate the benefactors, often mention gifts of hundreds of cows, but few horses VII.18.22 RV-23 is about 200 cows and four horses offered as a reward by the king victorious Sudās ... And the famous horse sacrifice ( Asvamedha ) was made only by the king who wanted to celebrate his world domination ...
On the other hand, if it is true that the horse becomes more frequent in the late Harappa (post-1900 BC), this is precisely the period in which to place most of the drafting of the Rgveda.

But apart from the representations we have the concrete evidence of horse bones, which are second Calasso to grasp the deniers of the invasion ... really seem to be rather the invasion scramble to deny the existence of these bones, as seen from the narrative of about Danino Hallur in Karnataka, where they were found horse bones dated between 1500 and 1300 BC, a bit 'too soon for a site in southern India:

"the excavation (in the late 1960s) That Were Brought Out horse remains dated Between 1500 and 1300 the ECB, in other words, about the time Aryans are pictured to Have galloped down the Khyber pass, some 2,000 [km.] north of Hallur. Even at a fierce Aryan pace, the animal could hardly have reached Karnataka by that time. When K.R. Alur, an archaeozoologist as well as a veterinarian, published his report on the animal remains from the site, he received anxious queries, even protests: there had to be some error regarding those horse bones. A fresh excavation was eventually undertaken some twenty years later — which brought to light more horse bones, and more consternation."

Ma, come scrisse l'archeologo S.P. Gupta nel suo The Indus-Saraswati Civilization, pp.159-163, Bhola Nath, "the most leading archaeo-zoologist of India" già nel 1968 identificò alcune delle ossa da Lothal (sito harappano del Gujarat) come di cavallo domesticato: Equus caballus Linn. Lo stesso riconobbe ossa di cavallo ad Harappa (livello maturo) e a Ropar nel Panjab. Nel 1974 A.K. Sharma identificò le ossa di Surkotada nel Kacch come di cavallo, e l'esperto di reperti equini ungherese Sándor Bökönyi confermò nel 1991 tale identificazione. Danino riporta anche il caso di Mahagara, vicino ad Allahabad, quindi in un'area molto più orientale, dove test al carbonio 14 sulle ossa di cavallo lì rinvenute hanno offerto datazioni tra il 2265 a.C. e il 1480 a.C. E il caso della valle del Chambal in Madhya Pradesh, dove M. K. Dhavalikar oltre alle ossa trovò una figurina di giumenta: "The most interesting is the discovery of bones of horse from the Kayatha levels and a terracotta figurine of a mare. It is the domesticate species (Equus caballus), which takes back the antiquity of the steed in India to the latter half of the third millennium BC."

Insomma, è assodato che nel III millennio a.C., in piena età harappana matura, il cavallo domestico era già ben presente, probabilmente importato, piuttosto che portato da invasori, dei quali gli archeologi (persino occidentali) non danno più conferma. Eppure, Calasso cita i "pochi elementi indubitabili" presentati da Frits Staal (illustre studioso di filosofia, linguistica e ritualismo vedico, ma non proprio uno storico o un archeologo) (pp.29-30): "More than three thousand years ago, small groups of semi-nomadic peoples crossed the mountainous regions on the border between Iran and Central Asia from the Indian subcontinent. [...] The interaction between these adventurers Central Asian and the previous inhabitants of the Indian subcontinent gave rise to the Vedic civilization [...]" In all this, of 'no doubt' there is nothing. A little 'later Calasso advances, however, some doubt on the recent trend of scholars "For fear of being accused of presenting as white Aryans predators [...] attenuated and rounded, as they could, the image of men vedic . Now there are more than conquerors who burst from the mountains and make iron and Fire the realm of native cruelly subjugated. Now is a group of emigrants who, in dribs and drabs, filter into new lands with hardly meet resistance, because the former Indus civilization was already settled, for reasons not ascertainable. Correction due, corresponding to thin the archaeological record, but sometimes suspected of an excess of zeal. "
must say that this correction does not match the 'thin' archaeological data. Calasso But following his Western academic sources, to depart But just when questioning the invasion. What is a reasonable point of view, since it is abbastanza inverosimile che un popolo possa prendere il sopravvento senza colpoferire: il fatto è che in questo modo torna al buon vecchio invasionismo ottocentesco.

Con tutto ciò non voglio certo demolire l'opera di Calasso, che mi si prospetta come straordinariamente preziosa in quanto sguardo fresco e inedito sulla civiltà vedica, con punti di vista non accademici che possono rivelare significati profondi. Voglio solo invitare chi, come lui, parla dell'India vedica anche da un punto di vista storico di approfondire il problema e non fermarsi alla versione di professori occidentali solo perché insegnano in università prestigiose. Invitation to study the views of archaeologists and Indian scholars, who may have more say about their history than they have German, French or American. And I'm a bit surprised 'that those who show love See how much the Calasso neglect their version of events, which does not include invasions from Central Asia, and the publisher of the classics of India traditionally preferred to adopt the perspective of modern Europeans than that handed down to millennia in the land of Bharata ...

0 comments:

Post a Comment