Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Gold Canyon Candles Riverside

Ardor and judgments of Indian history


On Sunday he appeared on TV, 'Che tempo che fa' , Roberto Calasso to talk about his latest book: "Ardor". Stimulating and worthwhile undertaking understanding of Indian civilization of the Vedas. For now I've only read interviews, presentations and short pieces, and I can not discuss the contents and interpretations, but what has already become clear is the presentation of the historical context of the Vedas quite in line with academic stereotypes. You can not blame Calasso have followed the classical sources dell'indologia, but the fact that a study of 15 years (many called for the preparation of this work) did not take up alternative theories that more than 15 years have been made about the Vedic Aryans and their relationship with the Harappan civilization, is significant and quite sad. Calasso gave a presentation of 'Frawley's paradox' (the American scholar who supports a form of identity-Vedic Harappan): a material civilization (the Harappan) without a word and a word (the Vedas) without material traces. But accepting it without recognizing the inherent improbability, as a fascinating enigma. It 's true that the Vedic civilization has left few traces, not the Vedic sacrifices made use of temples and (with some exceptions) of images, but huts and sacred fires. On the other hand, think that the Harappan civilization, which occupies a million square kilometers. and includes hundreds of sites, some very wide, and made use of a complex writing, has disappeared without leaving a memory of itself, it is untenable. And so, a work that will play an important role on the popular See continue to inculcate the usual myth of the descent of the Aryans from mysterious places in 1500 BC, leading the horse and the wheel spokes (who also existed in the Harappan civilization: were found denti di cavallo in vari siti, e la ruota raggiata appare sia come simbolo della scrittura dei sigilli sia nelle linee dipinte su apparenti ruote piene dei carretti di terracotta). E milioni di telespettatori hanno imparato questa versione della storia dell'India e degli Arii come un dato di fatto... non mi presterò anch'io a chiedere un contraddittorio, del resto la trasmissione di Fazio non è un documentario di storia, però sarebbe venuto il momento di poter diffondere versioni più fondate del contesto in cui è cresciuta la civiltà vedica, radice della civiltà dell'India e ramo possente del grande albero indoeuropeo...

0 comments:

Post a Comment